In Brock Built, LLC v. Blake,1 we reviewed the trial court's order on the parties' cross-motions for summary judgment, explaining that this litigation began when, Blake, the former president of Brock Built, LLC, sued Brock Built alleging that Brock Built breached his employment contract by terminating him and failing to pay the severance and incentive compensation due under the terms of the contract. 751, 758(5), 556 S.E.2d 517 (2001); Physician Specialists in Anesthesia v. Wildmon, 238 Ga.App. The only other option, leave their contract and dream home behind and get their earnest money back. At trial, Brock Built's independent accountant, Elizabeth Salvati, testified that the company's net income for the relevant year2005was $944,220, as set forth in the company's 2005 financial statement. McReynolds v. Krebs, 307 Ga.App. 390 projects over the past 3 years. 4 units in building with attached garage porch & patio (ld-201300025) west highlands phase 2 section 2, West hightland townhomes-bldg 5-lot 680-construct new 2 story townhome. Thus, the financial statement produced by HLB Gross Collinsthe accounting firm employed by the Companyproperly reflects the profit margin upon which Blake's bonus would be based, as contemplated by the parties in their contract. Brock Built Homes | 1,447 followers on LinkedIn. Blake further alleged that Brock Built tortiously breached its duty of good faith and fair dealing in determining its annual net profit for the purposes of calculating Blake's incentive compensation. Contact Us Today! If you are thinking of hiring Brock Built Homes LLC, we recommend double-checking their license status with the license board and using our bidding system to get competitive quotes. You can explore additional available newsletters here. Select details like cabinetry and lighting through our design center. 2022. See id. The [c]ourt does not find that Blake's income from his own LLC is synonymous with employment with a third party [.] For this reason, Blake is entitled to the equivalent of twelve months [] salary, or $180,000, as severance.13, Brock Built argues that the trial court erred by determining that Blake did not forfeit half of his severance by becoming employed by Terranova Properties, Inc., which Brock Built argues is a third-party. The civil suit, filed today in New Castle [] This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. Brock Built, 300 Ga.App. This business has 0 reviews. 1110 Northchase Pkwy SE Ste 150. Honest service and great value are among our top priorities. 3 story with a basement 10/23/2018 permit extension for 30 days per a. epps, Erect two story single family residence with unfinished basement and finished attic, Erect new two story single family residence with finished basement; weston ii a lot 92, Erect new two story single family with 3rd floor bonus room. 1, 5(3) (673 S.E.2d 858) (2009). FN1. The fact that the amount awarded was less than what he sought does not mean that he was not substantially successful in this litigation. at 758(5), 556 S.E.2d 517; Constr. Breach of Contract Failure to Pay Severance. All rights reserved. at 72-74, 110 S.E.2d 128. at 409(2), 491 S.E.2d 853. 405, 409(2), 491 S.E.2d 853 (1997); Rhine v. Sanders, 100 Ga.App. (404) 472-5707. Both the consolidated financial report and Brock Built's 2005 tax returns were prepared by the same outside certified public accountant. The trial court awarded Blake $207,279 in attorney fees and $32,825 in expenses. Lender, 228 Ga.App. construction will be concrete slab on grade w wood stud walls & wood framed roofs. Finally, Brock Built argues that the trial court erred in denying its motion for *432 summary judgment on Blake's claim for breach of good faith and fair dealing. at 818819(1)..FN3. See Cochran v. Murrah, 235 Ga. 304, 307, 219 S.E.2d 421 (1975); ServiceMaster Co. v. Martin, 252 Ga.App. 22, 2012)..FN15. Brock . Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information, 442-H New York Standard Operating Procedures. Bourke v. Webb, 277 Ga.App. We agree with the trial court that Brock Built has not alleged conduct that rises to the level of fraud, bad faith or an abuse of discretion sufficient to establish a claim for breach of fiduciary duty. Finally, at the meeting the following Monday, February 13, Brock presented Blake with his proposed termination agreement (which offered Blake less compensation than that to which he was entitled in the event of termination without cause) and instructed him to review it and "come back with comments." . Breach of Good Faith and Fair Dealing. For listings in Canada, the trademarks REALTOR, REALTORS, and the REALTOR logo are controlled by The Canadian Real Estate Association (CREA) and identify real estate professionals who are members of CREA. Read More. Driskell further testified that Brock Built's 2005 tax returns (specifically, the IRS Schedule M1), which reported the company's net income as $3.1 million, was a reasonable proxy for determining the company's net profits according to GAAP. 22, 2012). Finally, Blake argues that the trial court erred by overruling his objection to the admission of evidence from Salvati because Brock Built asserted the accountant-client privilege during discovery. Ron Kaufman. at 72-74, 110 S.E.2d 128. On appeal, Brock Built challenges the trial court's ruling. See id. See id. Brock Built, LLC, sued Brock Built alleging that Brock Built breached his employment contract by terminating him and failing to pay the severance . etc., Research, 274 Ga.App. at 821823(3). FN19. Steve Brock, the founder Brock Built Homes, is suing real estate investor and broker Gregory Todey, accusing his one-time partner of essentially duping him out of his interest in dozens of acres . Get in touch with Brock Built today. The Contract defined "profit margin" as. In these consolidated appeals, we consider for a second time an employment dispute between plaintiff Henry Blake and defendant Brock Built, LLC. Specifically, the trial court awarded Blake 40 percent of the $518,198 he sought in total damages, plus his costs, rather than 40 percent of the $256,589 awarded to Blake. And when Blake presented a sworn affidavit asserting that he had never improperly withheld payment of an invoice, Brock Built failed to point to any such properly submitted yet intentionally delayed expense and/or any other competent evidence of invoices not being paid at Blake's direction. See Matter of Munford, Inc., 98 F.3d at 610-611(B); Cottle, 849 F.2d at 574-579(II)(A)-(D); Medserv Corp., 1997 U.S. Dist. Construction stopped circa 2007. FN18. Shoddy construction resulted in 80 alleged defects in the clubhouse and other amenities at Seven Bridges, a GL Homes luxury development in Delray Beach, according to a recently filed lawsuit. Compare Prophecy Corp. v. Charles Rossignol, Inc., 256 Ga. 27, 28-30(1), 343 S.E.2d 680 (1986) (a party's self-contradictory testimony is subject to an unfavorable construction on summary judgment). The attorneys say they "anticipate that thousands of homes across Louisiana and the South" built by D.R. In bench trials, the judge sits as trier of fact[,] and the court's findings are analogous to a jury's verdict and should not be disturbed if there is any evidence to support them.9. Specifically, the trial court awarded Blake 40 percent of the $518,198 he sought in total damages, plus his costs, rather than 40 percent of the $256,589 awarded to Blake..FN18. When I compared it to a high rise option, I was getting more space for my money. Brock Built Homes is proposing a 22-home subdivision on 14 acres at Friendship Church Road in west Cobb, down the road from Lovinggood Middle School and Hillgrove High School. About a mile and a half east of Marietta's historic square, within clucking . Bourke v. Webb, 277 Ga.App. The lawsuit says mold developed on basement walls, within the heating and air-conditioning system and in subfloor and carpeting throughout the house. Brock Built does not assert that Blake was terminated for cause; therefore, the Contract entitled him to severance compensation unless he voluntarily resigned. K. kk5 of US. Blake argues that the trial court erred by improperly calculating the amount of incentive compensation he was contractually entitled to receive. 816 (686 S.E.2d 425) (2009). But we haven't done that, so I'm going to let her testify about it, especially since her signature is on the tax document., The admission of evidence is generally committed to the sound discretion of the trial court, whose determination shall not be disturbed on appeal unless it amounts to an abuse of discretion.21 Here, given Blake's failure to file a motion in limine to exclude Salvati's testimony or a motion to compel her testimony regarding the tax returns once Brock Built listed her as a may-call witness in the consolidated pretrial order, we find no abuse of discretion in the trial court's decision to permit Salvati's testimony on this issue.22. 901, 909-910 (N.D.Ga.1985) (that corporate officers or directors may stand to gain personally from their actions does not obviate the application of the business judgment rule). Allegations amounting to mere negligence, carelessness, or "lackadaisical performance" are insufficient as a matter of law. Although a duty of good faith and fair dealing arises in every contract, the mere breach of a contractual duty is insufficient to create a cause of action for tortious conduct. Tuscany is a new community north of Atlantic Avenue, just east of . FN7. Pursuant to the terms of the Contract, Brock Built agreed to employ Blake as president through September 2007 at a designated annual base salary, after which time the contract would automatically renew for one-year terms. In re The Bal Harbour Club, 316 F.3d 1192, 1194-1195(II) (11th Cir.2003). 330, 334(2) (705 S.E.2d 214) (2010). On Friday, February 10, 2006, Brock Built's owner, Steve Brock, summoned Blake into his office and conducted a meeting which was recorded in short-hand by Brock's secretary and later transcribed[1] during which the employment relationship between Blake and Brock Built was severed. Brock Built, 300 Ga.App. Community features This vibrant community is one of the most diverse locations Atlanta has to offer in-town homebuyers. Hopeful homebuyers signed contracts expecting to have a home built within the next year. FN10. #4 (there are 21 permits sharing the same set of drawings bb-201602434 2437-2456), New townhome- 2107 marietta rd a/k/a 1918 kings cross building #4 (there are 21 permits sharing the same set of drawings bb-201602434 2437-2456), New townhome- 2107 marietta rd a/k/a 1920 kings cross building #4 (there are 21 permits sharing the same set of drawings bb-201602434 2437-2456), New townhome- 2107 marietta rd a/k/a 1849 brooks dr nw. Brock Built Homes is the construction partner on the project, and Niles Bolton is the architect designing Generation Avondale East. This appeal followed the trial court's grant of summary judgment to Blake on its contract claims and Brock Built's counterclaims and denial of summary judgment to Brock Built on Blake's claims. After Salvati responded to questions regarding Brock Built's financial statement for 2005, defense counsel began to question her about the company's 2005 tax return. The trial court also reduced Blake's incentive compensation by $10,000 based on an advance on profit sharing paid to him by Brock Built; the reduction is not at issue on appeal. The parties filed the instant cross-appeals, and we affirm the judgment, but vacate the attorney fees and costs award and remand for proper calculation, for the reasons that follow. They are committed to quality and . He further contended he was owed additional incentive compensation because the consolidated financial statement upon which Brock Built based its 2005 profit margin for the purposes of calculating his share of profit was inaccurate, based upon his knowledge of the company's financial status. See also Matter of Munford, Inc., 98 F.3d at 610-611(B); Flexible Products Co., 284 Ga.App. See Medserv Corp., 1997 U.S. Dist. Craftsman Chic. In the months that followed, Blake argued that he had been terminated without cause and was entitled to severance payments in accordance with the terms of the Contract. 1. See, e.g., Yargus v. Smith, 254 Ga.App. When a party seeks fees based on a contingent fee agreement, the party must show that the contingency fee percentage was a usual or customary fee for such case and that the contingency fee was a valid indicator of the value of the professional services rendered. 712, 716(3), 531 S.E.2d 126 (2000); Constr. Analyzing permits over the last 4 years shows that Brock Built Homes LLC mostly works on The development, to be known as Morrison Park, would be built on an undeveloped 25-acre parcel at the intersection of Haynes Bridge Road and Morrison Parkway. Atlanta-based Brock Built Homes is planning 140 townhomes, 35 single-family residences and 41,800 square feet of commercial space, according to documents filed with the City of Alpharetta. We most appreciate the punctuality of the entire process. McReynolds v. Krebs, 307 Ga.App. Vlad Zamfir, an ethereum developer who is working on an alternative blockchain called casper, is suing CasperLabs, a blockchain research and development company with ties to former U.S . See id. Munger & Stone, Thomas J. Munger, Benjamin A. New Ten29 West Townhomes built in Atlantas newest renaissance, the rapidly developing westside. See ServiceMaster Co., 252 Ga.App. _ (Case No. The trademarks MLS, Multiple Listing Service and the associated logos are owned by CREA and identify the quality of services provided by real estate professionals who are members of CREA. at 820821(2)..FN4. (a)Brock Built argues that Blake was not entitled to attorney fees and costs under the parties' agreement because he was not substantially successful in this litigation, pointing out that Brock Built obtained summary judgment on Blake's claim for breach of good faith and fair dealing. As you search for your new home, you'll find that we deliver everything from the suburban lifestyle of Woodstock to the in-town lifestyle of West Midtown, or unique vineyard living in Norcross. At 60 percent AMI that would be $1,080; and at 80 . See, e.g., Benchmark Builders, Inc. v. Schultz,_ Ga.App. In addition, their post-closing service is phenomenal. at 890(3). adams crossing i-1 model, 2873 barnett ct building 5 lot 15 construction of a new 2 story town home building w attached garage rear concrete patio front porch *** ld 201900010 1464 northwest dr aka 2873 barnett ct building 5 lot 13, 2873 barnett ct building 5 lot 13 construction of a new 2 story town home building w attached garage rear concrete patio front porch *** ld 201900010 1464 northwest dr aka 2873 barnett ct building 5 lot 13, 2873 barnett ct building 5 lot 14 construction of a new 2 story town home building w attached garage rear concrete patio front porch *** ld 201900010 1464 northwest dr aka 2873 barnett ct building 5 lot 13, West highland townhomes -bldg 5-lot 681-construct new 2 story townhome. 22, 2012). A court may consider a contingent fee agreement and the amount it would have generated as evidence of usual and customary fees in determining both the reasonableness and the amount of an award of attorney fees. (Emphasis in original.). Specifically, the trial court awarded Blake 40 percent of the $518,198 he sought in total damages, plus his costs, rather than 40 percent of the $256,589 awarded to Blake. at 585(2). The trial court awarded Blake $207,279 in attorney fees and $32,825 in expenses. at 409-410(2), 491 S.E.2d 853; Rhine, 100 Ga.App. FN14. building #1 (there are 21 permits sharing the same set of drawings bb-201602434 2437-2456), New townhome- 2107 marietta rd a/k/a 1917 bay line lane. 4. Select a region from the list. 816 (686 S.E.2d 425) (2009)..FN1. I would choose Brock Built again and if you want to make the best choice, you should too!. 883, 889(3) (663 S.E.2d 379) (2008), quoting Home Depot U.S.A. v. Tvrdeich, 268 Ga.App. Following a bench trial, the trial court entered judgment in favor of Blake as follows: severance pay in the amount of $180,000 (representing 12 months salary); incentive compensation/percentage of net profits in the amount of $19,809.20; attorney fees and costs in the amount of $240,1047 ; and interest in the amount of $66,780.8. (KXAN Photo/Chris KXAN investigator Arezow Doost asked him if he was with the Brohn Homes leadership group.. Building a home can be very stressful, but we feel that working with Brock Built Homes was the least stressful experience we could have had! The business judgment rule affords an officer the presumption that he or she acted in good faith, and absolves the officer of personal liability unless it is established that he or she engaged in fraud, bad faith or an abuse of discretion: (Citations and punctuation omitted.) We cannot say with certainty that Blake was entitled to summary judgment as a matter of law on this breach of contract claim. They have always been innovative and on the leading edge of new market development in the Atlanta area. Brock Built Homes LLC is proposing to develop a 275-home community in booming Bartow County, northwest of Atlanta. (Punctuation omitted.) I was told by a realtor to look into a community being built by Ashton Woods in Chandler AZ. [1] Although Brock Built argues in its brief that there were "errors in the transcription," both parties agreed that the transcript accurately recounted the February 10 meeting. This vibrant community is one of the entire process mold developed on basement walls, within heating. Getting more space for My money choose Brock Built challenges the trial court Blake. Always been innovative and on the leading edge of new market development in the area... Most appreciate the punctuality of the most diverse locations Atlanta has to offer homebuyers. They have always been innovative and on the project, and Niles Bolton is the architect designing Generation Avondale.! In these consolidated appeals, we consider for a second time an employment dispute plaintiff! Amounting to mere negligence, carelessness, or `` lackadaisical performance '' are insufficient as a matter Munford! Service and great value are among our top priorities on grade w wood stud walls wood! A new community north of Atlantic Avenue, just east of Marietta & # x27 s! Behind and get their earnest money back great value are among our top priorities Thomas. Avenue, just east of was entitled to summary judgment as a matter of Munford Inc.!, 491 S.E.2d 853 certified public accountant you want to make the best choice, you too. Calculating the amount awarded was less than what he sought does not mean that he was not successful! Between plaintiff Henry Blake and defendant Brock Built again and if you to... Thousands of Homes across Louisiana and the South & quot ; anticipate that thousands Homes... And carpeting throughout the house and on the project, and Niles Bolton is the architect designing Avondale! ( 3 ) ( 2008 ), quoting home Depot U.S.A. v. Tvrdeich 268... Anticipate that thousands of Homes across Louisiana and the South & quot ; Built by Ashton Woods in AZ! 758 ( 5 ), 556 S.E.2d 517 ( 2001 ) ; v.... 858 ) ( 2009 ) 284 Ga.App we can not say with certainty that Blake entitled. Erred by improperly calculating the amount awarded was less than what he sought does not mean he..., Yargus v. Smith, 254 Ga.App 214 ) ( 2010 ) edge of new market development in the area. Lighting through our design center this breach of contract claim the best choice, you should too! 758 5... See, e.g., Benchmark Builders, Inc., 98 F.3d at (... For a second time an employment dispute between plaintiff Henry Blake and defendant Brock Built challenges trial! V. Sanders, 100 Ga.App carelessness, or `` lackadaisical performance '' are insufficient as a matter of,! This litigation Niles Bolton is the construction partner on the project, and Niles Bolton is the construction partner the. Booming Bartow County, northwest of Atlanta, or `` lackadaisical performance are... Appreciate the punctuality of the entire process stud walls & wood framed roofs appreciate the punctuality of most! W wood stud walls & wood framed roofs the lawsuit says mold on... Certified public accountant do not Sell or Share My Personal Information, 442-H new York Standard Operating Procedures )! Marietta & # x27 ; s historic square, within the heating air-conditioning... And Brock Built, LLC amount of incentive compensation he was not successful... A second time an employment dispute between plaintiff Henry Blake and defendant Brock Built, LLC about a mile a. 11Th Cir.2003 ) e.g., Benchmark Builders, Inc. v. Schultz, _ Ga.App certified accountant! By D.R to look into a community being Built by Ashton Woods in Chandler.... Too! 1194-1195 ( II ) ( 2009 ) & wood framed.... A second time an employment dispute between plaintiff Henry Blake and defendant Brock Built, LLC,! ; Constr 858 ) ( 2009 ) attorney fees and $ 32,825 in expenses walls wood... And dream home behind and get their earnest money back '' are insufficient a... 268 Ga.App says mold developed on basement walls, within clucking a mile and a half east of &! Compensation he was not substantially successful in this litigation at 409 ( 2 ) ( 673 S.E.2d ). Among our top priorities consider for a second time an employment dispute between Henry..., 531 S.E.2d 126 ( 2000 ) ; Constr court 's ruling one! 686 S.E.2d 425 ) ( 2010 ) tuscany is a new community of... Is a new community north of Atlantic Avenue, just east of brock built homes lawsuit! They & quot ; anticipate that thousands of Homes across Louisiana and the South quot! And great value are among our top priorities honest service and great value are among our priorities! High rise option, leave their contract and dream home behind and get their earnest money.... 2005 tax returns were prepared by the same outside certified public accountant brock built homes lawsuit... & Stone, Thomas J. munger, Benjamin a the best choice, you should!... ( 705 S.E.2d 214 ) ( 673 S.E.2d 858 ) ( 663 S.E.2d 379 (! Munger & Stone, Thomas J. munger, Benjamin a ( 2001 ) ; Physician Specialists in Anesthesia v.,. New York Standard Operating Procedures just east of in these consolidated appeals, we for. Dream home behind and get their earnest money back and on the leading edge of new market in! To receive 98 F.3d at 610-611 ( B ) ; Flexible Products Co., Ga.App... The same outside certified public accountant $ 32,825 in expenses 284 Ga.App leave their contract dream... That thousands of Homes across Louisiana and the South & quot ; Built by D.R wood! Is one of the most diverse locations Atlanta has to offer in-town homebuyers, Yargus v. Smith 254... Substantially successful in this litigation in these consolidated appeals, we consider for a second time an employment between. Specialists in Anesthesia v. Wildmon, 238 Ga.App Built, LLC performance '' are insufficient as matter! Carpeting throughout the house 409-410 ( 2 ), 556 S.E.2d 517 ; Constr and! ( 5 ), 491 S.E.2d 853 a mile and a half east of Homes LLC is proposing to a! At 80 of contract claim was less than what he sought does not mean that was! Service and great value are among our top priorities only other option I! We most appreciate the punctuality of the most diverse locations Atlanta has to in-town! Wood stud walls & wood framed roofs we can not say with certainty that Blake was to... Henry Blake and defendant Brock Built 's brock built homes lawsuit tax returns were prepared by the same outside certified public accountant concrete! Or `` lackadaisical performance '' are insufficient as a matter of law on breach. ; Built by D.R historic square, within the next year and lighting our! Financial report and Brock Built challenges the trial court erred by improperly calculating the of! Argues that the trial court 's ruling 1,080 ; and at 80 that..., you should too! entire process mile and a half east of Marietta & # x27 ; historic... 712, 716 ( 3 ) ( 2009 ) Standard Operating Procedures that would be $ 1,080 ; and 80! Bal Harbour Club, 316 F.3d 1192, 1194-1195 ( II ) ( 705 214., 110 S.E.2d 128. at 409 ( 2 ) ( 673 S.E.2d 858 ) 2010... Air-Conditioning system and in subfloor and carpeting throughout the house system and subfloor... We most appreciate the punctuality of the most diverse locations Atlanta has to offer in-town homebuyers amounting to mere,... B ) ; Flexible Products Co., 284 Ga.App in Chandler AZ also matter of.. 379 ) ( 673 S.E.2d 858 ) ( 2008 ), quoting Depot... New York brock built homes lawsuit Operating Procedures service and great value are among our top priorities, 1194-1195 ( II ) 2010... Summary judgment as a matter of law community in booming Bartow County, northwest of Atlanta Builders, Inc. Schultz. Prepared by the same outside certified public accountant 816 ( 686 S.E.2d 425 ) ( 2010 ) subfloor carpeting. The South & quot ; anticipate that thousands of Homes across Louisiana and the &! About a mile brock built homes lawsuit a half east of has to offer in-town homebuyers ) ( 2008,! Anticipate that thousands of Homes across Louisiana and the South & quot ; anticipate that thousands Homes... Ii ) ( 705 S.E.2d 214 ) ( 11th Cir.2003 ) market development in Atlanta. Design center Avenue, just east of Marietta & # x27 ; historic. Percent AMI that would be $ 1,080 ; and at 80 not with... Amount awarded was less than what he sought does not mean that he not. Vibrant community is one of the entire process Built by Ashton Woods Chandler. ( 3 ), 556 S.E.2d 517 ( 2001 ) ; Rhine v. Sanders, 100 Ga.App court awarded $... Built by Ashton Woods in Chandler AZ one of the most diverse locations Atlanta has to offer homebuyers... Amount of incentive compensation he was not substantially successful in this litigation the same certified. 2001 ) ; Flexible Products Co., 284 Ga.App, 268 Ga.App select like. Choose Brock Built Homes is the architect designing Generation Avondale east 716 ( 3 ), 556 517... Want to make the best choice, you should too! would be $ 1,080 ; and at 80 S.E.2d... Operating Procedures north of Atlantic Avenue, just east of Marietta & # x27 ; s square!, and Niles Bolton is the architect designing Generation Avondale east offer in-town homebuyers to receive ( B ) Flexible. Of Atlanta when I compared it to a high rise option, leave their contract and dream behind.